Building without dommages-ouvrage insurance in France: what are the risks and what are the solutions?

The quote for the dommages-ouvrage insurance (the French building damage insurance taken out by the project owner) has just arrived and the amount is making you hesitate. The builder tells you that “everybody does without it”, that his ten-year liability insurance (garantie décennale) is enough and that work can start next week. The temptation to save on this insurance is real, especially for a private individual having a house or an extension built. Yet building without dommages-ouvrage insurance is far more than a forgotten formality: it is a breach of a legal obligation, which in some cases carries criminal penalties, and above all a financial risk that can prove very heavy in the event of a claim or if the property is sold within ten years.

In one of our previous articles, we set out the differences between dommages-ouvrage insurance and the ten-year liability guarantee and the obligations of each party. This article goes further and takes the point of view of the project owner (maître d’ouvrage) who has not taken out this insurance, or who is considering not taking it out: what exactly does the law say, who risks what, what happens if defects appear, and what are the consequences when the property is sold?

What does the law provide regarding dommages-ouvrage insurance?

An obligation laid down by Article L. 242-1 of the French Insurance Code

The obligation to take out dommages-ouvrage insurance stems from Article L. 242-1 of the French Insurance Code (Code des assurances). This provision requires any natural or legal person who, acting as owner of the works, seller or agent of the owner, has construction work carried out, to take out, before work begins on site, on its own behalf or on behalf of subsequent owners, insurance guaranteeing, without any need to establish liability, payment of the full cost of repairing damage of the kind for which builders are liable under Article 1792 of the French Civil Code.

Three elements of this definition deserve emphasis. First, the obligation rests on the project owner, meaning you when you have a building built, and not on the contractors. Second, it must be fulfilled before work begins on site, not when a problem arises. Third, the insurance also benefits subsequent owners: it follows the property, which explains its importance on resale.

Pre-financing insurance, distinct from the ten-year liability guarantee

As we explained in our article on the differences between dommages-ouvrage insurance and the ten-year liability guarantee, the garantie décennale is a liability borne by builders under Article 1792 of the French Civil Code, which they are required to insure. Dommages-ouvrage insurance, by contrast, is property insurance taken out by the project owner. Its purpose is to fund repairs quickly, without waiting for a court to determine who is liable.

Article L. 242-1 of the French Insurance Code sets strict time limits for the insurer. The insurer has sixty days from receipt of the claim notification to notify its decision on whether the claim is covered. If it accepts cover, it must submit an offer of compensation within a maximum of ninety days from that same notification, then pay within fifteen days of acceptance of the offer. If the insurer fails to meet these deadlines or makes a manifestly inadequate offer, the insured may, after notifying the insurer, incur the expenses necessary for the repairs, and the compensation is then automatically increased by interest at twice the statutory interest rate.

The provision also states that the insurance, which normally takes over once the one-year completion guarantee period (garantie de parfait achèvement) has expired, covers the cost of repairs even before that period ends in two situations: where, before acceptance of the works, the contractor’s contract is terminated for non-performance after a formal notice has gone unheeded, and where, after acceptance, the contractor has failed to perform its obligations despite formal notice.

It is precisely this whole set of fast, regulated protections that a project owner gives up by building without dommages-ouvrage insurance.

Which works are covered?

The obligation applies to construction works likely to engage the builders’ ten-year liability. It naturally covers the construction of a detached house or a building, but also works on existing structures which themselves constitute a construction, such as an extension, a raised storey or a major renovation affecting the structure.

Article L. 243-1-1 of the French Insurance Code, however, excludes certain works from the obligation, in particular maritime, road and port works and, unless they are ancillary to works subject to the obligation, roadways, car parks, utility networks, pipelines and uncovered sports facilities. The same article states that the insurance obligation does not apply to structures existing before work begins on site, except those which, being fully incorporated into the new works, become technically indivisible from them.

Practical example: Julie has a 30 m² extension built onto her house, with foundations, load-bearing walls and a roof. The extension is new construction subject to the dommages-ouvrage insurance obligation. The older part of the house, however, is not covered by this insurance, unless it is fully incorporated into the new works to the point of becoming technically indivisible from them.

Who is exempt from the obligation?

Article L. 242-1 itself provides for limited exceptions. The obligation does not apply to public-law legal entities, to certain legal entities acting as project owner under partnership contracts, or to legal entities whose business exceeds certain thresholds set by the text, when they have works carried out on their own behalf for a use other than housing.

None of these exceptions covers the private individual having a house built, or the investor, whether an individual or an SCI (French property-holding company), having homes built. For them, the obligation to take out the insurance applies in full as soon as they have construction work carried out.

The specific case of self-build

The situation of a person who builds his or her own house, without using any contractor, calls for a specific analysis. The text targets the person who “has” construction work “carried out”, which implies the involvement of builders. This is why it is generally accepted that a person who builds entirely on their own is not covered by the obligation, as we explained in our previous article.

In practice, the situation is rarely so clear-cut. As soon as you entrust part of the work to professionals (earthworks, foundations, roof frame, roofing), you are having that work carried out by builders and the analysis changes. The line between self-build and conventional project ownership must therefore be assessed case by case, and it is wise to seek advice before concluding that the obligation does not apply to you.

What criminal penalties do you face if you build without dommages-ouvrage insurance?

The rule: an offence punishable by six months’ imprisonment and a €75,000 fine

Article L. 243-3 of the French Insurance Code provides that anyone who breaches Articles L. 241-1 to L. 242-1 of that code is punishable by six months’ imprisonment and a fine of €75,000, or by one of these two penalties only. Failure by a project owner who is required to do so to take out dommages-ouvrage insurance is therefore a criminal offence.

The exception: individuals building a home for themselves or their family

The second paragraph of Article L. 243-3 provides for an important exception: these penalties do not apply to a natural person building a dwelling to occupy it personally or to have it occupied by his or her spouse, ascendants or descendants, or those of his or her spouse.

This exception must be properly understood. It does not remove the insurance obligation: it only rules out the criminal penalty. A private individual who has his or her main residence built without dommages-ouvrage insurance remains in breach of Article L. 242-1 and bears all the civil and financial consequences of the lack of cover, which we describe below. He or she simply escapes criminal prosecution.

The exception is also narrowly defined. It applies only to a natural person, for the construction of a dwelling, and for occupation by that person or by the family members exhaustively listed in the text. The text mentions the spouse but does not expressly refer to a civil partner (PACS) or cohabiting partner; the wording of the article does not settle their situation.

Investors and SCIs do not benefit from the exception

For investors, the consequence is direct. An SCI is a legal entity: it cannot rely on the exception reserved for natural persons. Likewise, an individual who has a dwelling built to let it to third parties is not building to occupy it personally or have it occupied by family within the meaning of the text. In both cases, the absence of dommages-ouvrage insurance exposes the project owner to the penalties set out in Article L. 243-3 of the French Insurance Code.

Practical example: Marc has a house built that he will live in with his wife. He does not take out dommages-ouvrage insurance. He does not face criminal prosecution, but he loses all the protection this insurance provides. At the same time, his brother Paul has two semi-detached houses built through a family SCI in order to let them. Without dommages-ouvrage insurance, Paul’s SCI is exposed to the criminal penalties of Article L. 243-3 of the French Insurance Code, in addition to the civil consequences.

While the criminal risk is therefore limited for an individual building a home for themselves, it is on the financial side that the absence of insurance has its most tangible effects.

What happens if defects appear and there is no dommages-ouvrage insurance?

You keep your remedies against the builders

A common misconception needs to be dispelled: the absence of dommages-ouvrage insurance does not deprive you of your rights against the builders. The ten-year liability under Article 1792 of the French Civil Code continues to apply. Contractors remain strictly liable, for ten years from acceptance of the works, for damage that compromises the soundness of the building or makes it unfit for its intended use, and they must be insured for this liability.

What changes is the way you obtain compensation. With dommages-ouvrage insurance, you notify the claim to your own insurer, which must decide within regulated time limits and pre-finance the repairs; it is then for the insurer to seek recovery from the builders and their insurers. Without this insurance, you are the one who must identify the party or parties liable, gather the evidence and then obtain a judgment against them or their insurers, which in practice can take a long time.

A longer and more costly legal route

Without dommages-ouvrage insurance, the usual route is to apply to the interim relief judge (juge des référés) for the appointment of a court-appointed expert, whose task is to describe the defects, investigate their causes and estimate the cost of repairs. Only once the expert’s report is issued can you, where appropriate, bring proceedings on the merits against the contractors and their insurers. Throughout this period, which can last several years, the defects remain and you must pay the procedural and expert costs upfront.

The difficulties multiply when several contractors were involved and blame one another, when one of them has disappeared or gone into liquidation, or when it turns out that one of the parties was not insured for the activity actually carried out. Dommages-ouvrage insurance would have neutralised precisely these uncertainties, since it pays out without any need to establish liability.

Time limits for taking action become a major issue

Without dommages-ouvrage insurance, close attention to time limits is essential. The ten-year period runs from acceptance of the works and is a foreclosure period (délai de forclusion). As we explained in an article on the builder’s acknowledgement of liability, this period is not interrupted by the builder’s promises or remedial works: only legal proceedings, even interim proceedings, can interrupt it. An uninsured project owner, who can rely only on action against the builders, must therefore never let time pass while counting on an amicable solution.

Practical example: Sophie had her house built without dommages-ouvrage insurance, with acceptance of the works in April 2019. In 2025, significant cracks appear in a load-bearing wall. The bricklayer promises to come and fix them, then stops responding; she then discovers that his company has gone into liquidation. Sophie must now track down the bricklayer’s ten-year liability insurer, using the certificate provided when the quote was signed, and bring summary proceedings for an expert appraisal against it, making sure to act before April 2029. Had she taken out dommages-ouvrage insurance, she could have notified the claim to her own insurer, which would have been required to give its decision within sixty days.

The case of the detached house construction contract

When you have a house built under a detached house construction contract with supply of plans (contrat de construction de maison individuelle, CCMI), the French Construction and Housing Code (Code de la construction et de l’habitation) builds dommages-ouvrage insurance into the contract itself. Article L. 231-2 of that code requires the contract to state the reference of the damage insurance taken out by the project owner pursuant to Article L. 242-1 of the French Insurance Code. Article L. 231-4 of the same code also allows the contract to be entered into subject to the condition precedent of obtaining that damage insurance.

This legal framework shows that, when a detached house is built by a professional builder, dommages-ouvrage insurance is designed as a standard part of the project set-up, not as an option.

What happens if you sell the property within ten years?

The sale remains possible

The absence of dommages-ouvrage insurance does not prevent a sale. The French Court of Cassation (Cour de cassation) has clearly held that failure to take out this insurance, which is not an indispensable accessory of the property sold, does not prevent the sale of the building (Cass. 3e civ., 2 March 2011, No. 09-72.576, published in the Bulletin). In that case, the buyer complained that the seller had not transferred dommages-ouvrage insurance covering a covered outdoor area the seller had built; the Court rejected the argument based on the obligation of delivery.

The obligation to mention the absence of insurance in the deed

The sale is, however, subject to a duty to inform. Article L. 243-2 of the French Insurance Code requires that, where a deed entered into before expiry of the ten-year period provided for in Article 1792-4-1 of the French Civil Code transfers ownership or use of the property, other than leases, the existence or absence of the compulsory insurance policies be stated in the body of the deed or in an annex. In practice, the notary must state in the deed of sale that dommages-ouvrage insurance was not taken out.

This transparency protects the buyer, who must be able to know the situation. It also protects the seller, since a clearly informed buyer will find it difficult to later accuse the seller of failing in the duty to inform. In the judgment of 2 March 2011 cited above, the Court of Cassation indeed upheld the lower court’s rejection of the claim of lack of fair dealing, since the insurance certificate annexed to the deed and initialled by the buyer clearly showed the limits of the cover taken out.

In practice, negotiations are often harder

Beyond the legal position, the absence of dommages-ouvrage insurance frequently weighs on negotiations. An informed buyer knows that, in the event of a defect falling under the ten-year liability, there will be no pre-financing and action will have to be taken against the builders. The buyer may use this to negotiate the price, request technical surveys before committing, or walk away from the purchase. The buyer’s own financing may also be complicated, depending on the bank’s requirements. The extent of these effects depends on each situation and cannot be quantified in general terms.

The seller is deemed to be a builder

The most significant issue for the seller lies in the seller’s own liability. Article 1792-1, 2°, of the French Civil Code deems to be a builder of the works any person who sells, after completion, a building that he or she has built or had built. A private individual who resells, within ten years, the house he or she had built is therefore subject, towards the buyer, to the same ten-year liability as the contractors, running from acceptance of the works.

This liability cannot be excluded by a clause in the deed of sale. Article 1792-5 of the French Civil Code deems unwritten any clause intended to exclude or limit the liability provided for in particular in Articles 1792 and 1792-1. A clause stating that the buyer “takes responsibility” for defects falling under the ten-year liability therefore has no effect on that liability.

In concrete terms, if a defect falling under the ten-year liability appears after the sale, the buyer may bring a claim against you as a seller deemed to be a builder, and it will then be for you to pursue your own remedies against the contractors involved and their insurers. Without dommages-ouvrage insurance, no insurer steps in to pre-finance the repairs for the buyer.

The seller who took part in the works personally

The situation is even more delicate when the seller personally designed or carried out part of the works. The Court of Cassation upheld the decision of a court of appeal which, having found that a seller had acted as project manager, bought the materials, and designed and partly installed a heating system that caused a fire, treated him as a professional seller presumed to know of the defect, which deprived him of the benefit of the clause excluding the warranty against latent defects stipulated in the deed of sale (Cass. 3e civ., 9 February 2011, No. 09-71.498, published in the Bulletin).

For a private individual who built partly on his or her own and without insurance, the usual clause excluding the warranty against latent defects is therefore not reliable protection.

Liability of intermediaries and compensation of the buyer

A buyer who was not informed of the absence of insurance may also seek to hold liable the professionals involved in the sale, in particular the notary or the estate agent, for breach of their duty to inform and advise. The recoverable loss is, however, limited by case law. The Court of Cassation overturned a decision ordering the seller, the notaries and the commercial agent to pay the full cost of the repairs, because the lower court had not established that it was certain that the buyers, had they been better informed, could have taken out insurance covering the defects or obtained an equivalent price reduction; it reiterated that compensation for a loss of chance cannot equal the benefit the hoped-for outcome would have provided (Cass. 1re civ., 9 December 2010, No. 09-69.490, published in the Bulletin).

This case law illustrates a key point for the buyer: where there is no dommages-ouvrage insurance, action against intermediaries does not necessarily provide full compensation. The main remedy remains the ten-year liability claim against the seller deemed to be a builder and against the contractors.

Practical example: In 2026, Thomas sells the house he had built in 2021 without dommages-ouvrage insurance. The deed mentions the absence of insurance. After the sale, subsidence of the floor slab makes part of the house unfit for its intended use. The buyer brings a claim against Thomas under Articles 1792 and 1792-1 of the French Civil Code. Thomas cannot rely on a clause excluding liability, which is deemed unwritten. He will have to defend himself and bring third-party proceedings against the structural works contractor and its ten-year liability insurer, while complying with the time limits running from acceptance of the works in 2021.

Why do some project owners build without dommages-ouvrage insurance?

The cost of the insurance

The first reason given is cost. The amount of the premium depends on the project, its cost, its technical nature and the parties involved, and cannot be estimated in general terms. This cost should be weighed against what it protects: fast pre-financing of repairs which, under the ten-year liability regime, concern the structure, the weathertightness or the habitability of the property.

Refusal by insurers

The second reason relates to difficulties in obtaining insurance. Some project owners are refused cover, in particular when the file is incomplete, when some of the parties involved cannot prove they hold ten-year liability insurance, or when the project has particular technical features.

The law provides a solution. Article L. 243-4 of the French Insurance Code allows any person subject to the insurance obligation who has been refused cover by an insurance company whose articles of association do not prohibit it from covering the risk to refer the matter to the Central Pricing Office (Bureau central de tarification, BCT). The BCT’s sole role is to set the premium in return for which the insurer must cover the risk, and it may set an excess to be borne by the insured.

This mechanism was strengthened by Law No. 2026-403 of 26 May 2026 on the simplification of economic life. Since 28 May 2026, Article L. 243-4 of the French Insurance Code has specified that a refusal of cover must mention the possibility of referring the matter to the Central Pricing Office and explain how to do so, and that the BCT must rule within three months. A refusal of insurance is therefore not, in itself, a justification for building without dommages-ouvrage insurance: it opens up a remedy that should be used before work begins on site.

Common misconceptions

Finally, failure to take out the insurance is often based on misconceptions. It is wrong to think that the contractors’ ten-year liability insurance makes dommages-ouvrage insurance unnecessary: the two mechanisms are complementary and do not operate at the same time or in the same way. It is equally wrong to believe that a building constructed without insurance is irregular with regard to the building permit: dommages-ouvrage insurance falls under insurance law, not planning law, and its absence does not, in itself, affect the validity of the planning permission.

Frequently asked questions from private individuals

Can I take out dommages-ouvrage insurance after work has started?

The law requires the insurance to be taken out before work begins on site. It does not provide for any specific mechanism to regularise the situation once work has started. An insurer approached during construction, or after completion, remains free to assess the risk and set its own terms. If you have already started work without insurance, it is worth promptly reviewing your situation with a professional to find out what options are available to you.

My contractor has ten-year liability insurance: am I protected?

You have a claim against the contractor and its ten-year liability insurer, which is essential. However, that claim requires you to prove the contractor’s liability, usually following a court-appointed expert’s report, and it may run into difficulties when several parties are involved or when the insurance cover of one of them is disputed. Dommages-ouvrage insurance would have allowed you to be compensated without waiting for the outcome of these disputes.

I am building my main residence: am I required to take out dommages-ouvrage insurance?

Yes, if you have construction work carried out by professionals. The exception in Article L. 243-3 only rules out the criminal penalty for an individual building a dwelling for themselves or their close family. The obligation under Article L. 242-1 remains, as do all the civil consequences of the absence of insurance.

Can my bank require this insurance?

In practice, lenders frequently ask for a dommages-ouvrage insurance certificate to finance a construction project. The exact conditions depend on each loan offer, which should be read carefully before signing.

What should I do if a defect appears and I have no dommages-ouvrage insurance?

You should gather the key documents without delay: the record of acceptance of the works, quotes and invoices, the ten-year liability insurance certificates of each contractor, and photographs and reports of the defects. The next step is to identify the likely cause of the defect and, if no quick solution is found, to bring summary proceedings for an expert appraisal (référé-expertise) against the builders concerned and their insurers, specifying each defect precisely and acting before the ten-year period expires.

Practical tips to secure your project

The first precaution is to build dommages-ouvrage insurance into the project timeline, as soon as the building permit has been obtained and the contractors have been chosen. Insurers generally require a complete file, including a description of the works and the insurance certificates of the parties involved. Planning ahead prevents the insurance from becoming the last step holding up the start of work.

The second precaution is to check the ten-year liability insurance certificates of each contractor. Article L. 243-2 of the French Insurance Code provides that these certificates must be attached to professionals’ quotes and invoices. Check that the declared activities match the works entrusted to them. This check helps you obtain dommages-ouvrage insurance, and it becomes vital if you do not have it.

The third precaution concerns refusal of cover. Keep the refusal letter, check that it mentions the possibility of referring the matter to the Central Pricing Office, and take this step before work begins.

The fourth precaution is to plan ahead for resale. If you have built without dommages-ouvrage insurance and intend to sell within ten years, put together a complete technical file, inform the buyer clearly and make sure the deed mentions the absence of insurance, in accordance with Article L. 243-2. Bear in mind that you will remain liable as a seller deemed to be a builder.

The fifth precaution is to keep all the construction documents for at least ten years from acceptance of the works, and to act quickly if a defect appears, relying only on legal proceedings to interrupt the ten-year period.

Practical example: Claire and Antoine obtain their building permit in March. A first insurer refuses to cover their project because one of the contractors has not yet provided his ten-year liability insurance certificate. Rather than start without insurance, they obtain the missing certificate, submit a complete file to a second insurer and, if refused again, plan to refer the matter to the Central Pricing Office. Work starts a few weeks late, but with protection that will follow the property if it is sold.

Conclusion: building without dommages-ouvrage insurance, a risk that often costs you later

Building without dommages-ouvrage insurance means failing to comply with the obligation laid down by Article L. 242-1 of the French Insurance Code. For an individual building a dwelling for themselves or their close family, the criminal penalty is ruled out by Article L. 243-3. For an investor, an SCI or an owner building to let, the offence is made out and carries six months’ imprisonment and a €75,000 fine.

In all cases, the civil consequences remain. If defects appear, the project owner must take action alone against the builders, pay the costs upfront and comply with a ten-year period that nothing other than legal proceedings can interrupt. On resale within ten years, the absence of insurance must be mentioned in the deed, may weigh on negotiations, and the seller remains liable to the buyer as a seller deemed to be a builder, with no possibility of escaping that liability through a clause in the deed.

A refusal by an insurer should not lead you to give up on insurance: since the Law of 26 May 2026, a refusal must mention the possibility of referring the matter to the Central Pricing Office, which rules within three months.

If you are preparing a construction project, have already started work without dommages-ouvrage insurance, have noticed defects in an uninsured building or are considering buying or selling a property less than ten years old in this situation, it is strongly recommended that you consult a lawyer specialising in construction law. A lawyer can analyse your situation, secure your remedies and the applicable time limits, and assist you throughout the process.

 

Archives